Forsaken for an Illusion: Claimed by the Rival

The Unwanted Return

Author: undefined

The Unwanted Return

*Lyra*

Five months. One hundred and fifty grueling days had dragged by since the devastating afternoon Rowan rejected me, taking my beating heart and shattering it into a million jagged pieces. Five agonizing months of phantom pains echoing in my chest where our sacred bond used to thrive. Slowly, painstakingly, I had started to piece my fractured soul back together. I could not have survived it alone. Declan was my rock through the unending storm. He never pushed for more than I could give. He offered a steady hand, gentle words, and unwavering daily support. He created a safe haven for me. When I was with Declan, I felt glimpses of the carefree fifteen-year-old girl I used to be, long before pack duty and cruel betrayal ruined my life.

Yet, I knew I kept him at arm's length. Every time he suggested a run through the forest or a simple walk across the pack lands, I found a convenient excuse to hide in my room. I buried my focus in embroidery, letting the quiet, repetitive motion soothe my anxious mind. Today, though, I made a fierce determination to change. I wanted to take a tangible step forward. I needed to reclaim my life from the shadows of my past. Rowan was out there living his perfect life with another woman, preparing for a child, and it was time I stopped playing the tragic victim.

"Hey, are you up for a walk today?"

I lifted my head from my embroidery hoop. Declan stood leaning against my bedroom doorframe. He looked as handsome as ever, his posture relaxed, his tone carrying a familiar hopeful lilt.

I set the cloth on the bedside table and grabbed my warm coat. "Yes."

Surprise flickered across his sharp features before a warm, genuine smile broke through. He had not expected me to agree. A sharp twinge of guilt pricked my conscience. He tried so hard to bring me out of my shell. It was time I tried for him, too.

Declan offered his arm as I approached. I looped mine through his, letting him guide me out of the room and down the wide wooden staircase of the Alpha house. His strong presence felt grounding.

"So," Declan started, keeping his tone light and conversational, "I’ve been thinking about what to do for your birthday next week."

I stiffened on the step, my grip tightening on his arm. Twenty. I was turning twenty next week. The milestone had slipped my mind amid the suffocating grief.

"I know it's been a while since you’ve seen them," Declan continued, his thumb brushing a comforting rhythm against the back of my hand, trying to create a sense of normalcy, "so I was hoping we could invite Kaelen and Bree to—"

A sudden explosive crash shattered the peaceful morning.

A terrifying angry commotion erupted from the kitchen at the far end of the hall. Heavy boots scraped against the floorboards, followed by a harsh guttural growl that made the hair on the back of my neck stand up.

My heart stopped dead in my chest.

Declan dropped my arm instantly. His relaxed demeanor vanished in a split second, replaced by lethal commanding Alpha fury. He stormed ahead toward the noise, his broad shoulders squared for a fight. I remained frozen on the bottom stair. My feet felt glued to the floorboards. My breath trapped itself in my throat, refusing to move.

Then the scent hit me.

Deep musk, rain-soaked cedar, and raw power.

It engulfed the hallway, wrapping around my senses like a physical snare. Rowan. My inner wolf, who had curled up in a dormant silent ball of misery since the rejection, roared awake. She clawed frantic at my chest, threatening to unravel all the fragile emotional walls I had built over the last five months.

Tears prickled the corners of my eyes. I stumbled sideways, my shoulder slamming hard against the hall table. A decorative vase wobbled and tipped over, hitting the floor with a dull thud. My frantic instincts screamed at me to run back up the stairs, lock the door, and hide under the covers until his intoxicating scent faded away.

"Where is she, Gideon? I won't ask you again."

The deep rumbling voice vibrated through the walls. It was him. It was really him.

"Oh, hell no!" Declan’s voice boomed from the kitchen, seething with pure rage. "You are not going anywhere near her. You need to get the hell off my pack lands right now."

Silence hung heavy for a fraction of a second. My cousin Gideon was in there too, caught between his unwavering loyalty to me and his lifelong deep-rooted friendship with the Alpha who broke me.

"Get the hell out of my way, Declan," Rowan snarled back. "She needs to come home."

Flesh slapped against flesh. A heavy body slammed hard against the granite kitchen counters. A violent physical scuffle broke out, boots scuffing the tiles, a grunt of exertion tearing through the air.

"I said," Declan growled, his voice dropping into a deadly threatening register. "Get. Out. Of. My. Pack."

Ignoring the terror clawing at my throat, I forced my trembling legs to move. Knowing my world was about to fracture all over again, I stepped down the hall and stopped in the kitchen doorway.

"Declan," the word slipped from my lips.

Rowan froze. His fist was drawn back, ready to strike Declan’s jaw, but the sound of my voice made him snap his head in my direction.

Our eyes collided across the tense room.

My breath hitched in my throat. I took him in for the first time in five months. He looked rougher than the flawless polished Alpha I remembered. Dark shadows bruised the skin under his deep green eyes, making him look as though he had endured hell. A heavy layer of scruff coated his sharp jawline. Yet despite the haggard appearance, he still exuded that magnetic undeniable pull.

He stared direct at me. The icy hostility and duty-bound rigidity he wielded the day he broke me were gone. Instead, a startling raw and desperate longing burned in his gaze. He looked at me as if I was the only thing keeping him breathing.

Where was this look when he returned from the academy? Where was this desperate need when he chose another woman over our bond?

My blood boiled hot with pure unadulterated fury. The sheer audacity of this man to look at me with longing after destroying my life pushed past my fear.

"You need to leave," I forced the words out into the charged air.

I hated the sound of my own voice. It sounded broken, breathless, weak. I wanted to sound strong, commanding, unshakable. But the heavy tension in the room squeezed the breath from my lungs.

Rowan dropped his fist. He took a desperate physical step toward me, his heavy boots echoing on the tiles.

Declan instantly shifted his large frame, blocking the path. He created an impenetrable physical blockade between us, shielding me from Rowan's advance with his own body.

"Lyra..." Rowan murmured.

Hearing my name on his lips sent a jarring shockwave through my system. The tone was soft, stripped of the cold authority he used to sever our bond.

"You need to come home," Rowan continued, his eyes darting around Declan's broad shoulder to keep me in his sight. "Kaelen demands it."

A harsh bitter scoff ripped from my throat. I fought back a massive dam of tears threatening to spill and humiliate me in front of him. I refused to let him see me cry. I refused to look weak again.

"Tell Kaelen he can come fetch me himself," I spat, my voice gaining a fraction of steady ground. "Because there is no way in hell I am going anywhere with you."

The severed bond thrummed a dull agonizing ache in the back of my mind. It was dead, yet the phantom connection still recognized his presence, twisting the knife deeper.

Rowan shifted his weight, trying to find an angle around Declan. "We need to talk."

Declan did not yield an inch. He stood like a mountain of stone. Slowly, Declan glanced back over his shoulder. For a microsecond, his intense eyes softened as they met mine, checking on my fragile state. Then, his gaze turned back to lethal ice.

"Go to our room," Declan instructed, his voice ringing loud and clear in the tense silence. "I’ll be up in a second."

*Our room.*

The words hung heavy in the air. It was a calculated deliberate Alpha provocation, designed to strike Rowan right in his pride and mark territory.

It worked flawless.

Rowan’s confused expression morphed into sudden violent fury. The deep green of his eyes flared with uncontrollable jealousy. His canines elongated, resting sharp against his bottom lip. His entire body tensed, coiling tight for a lethal strike.

"What the fuck do you mean by 'our room'?" Rowan snarled, a feral vibration echoing from deep within his chest.

"None of your damn business, Rowan," Declan coldly threatened, his own aura expanding to dominate the kitchen. "Now I won't tell you again. Get off my property before I kill you where you stand. I have kept your neck intact for Lyra and Gideon's sake, knowing your past. But I am running out of patience."

Rowan’s gaze darkened dangerous. He shifted his focus off me and locked his murderous glare onto Declan.

"I’d like to see you try," Rowan challenged, his voice dripping with lethal venom. "Just remember what happened the last time you crossed me."

Declan visibly stiffened. A silent violent history passed between the two Alphas, likely some brutal clash from their academy days. I didn't care. I didn't care about their bruised egos, their territorial posturing, or Declan using my bedroom situation to piss Rowan off. I just wanted this nightmare to end.

The suffocating tension in the room spiked. The air grew thick, teetering on the edge of a bloodbath. They were seconds away from tearing each other apart right on the kitchen floor.

Gideon frantically stepped into the fray. He threw his hands up, wedging himself near the counter, torn. He loved me, his cousin, but his deeply ingrained friendship with Rowan pulled him in the opposite direction.

"Hey man, come on!" Gideon shouted, his voice laced with panic. "Look, I told you she wouldn't leave with you. Just step back."

Both Alphas let out low threatening rumbles. Neither wanted to back down. Declan protected his space, and Rowan remained obsessed with not leaving without me.

Gideon turned to Rowan, lowering his voice to a desperate promise. "Just give me a day. Give me a day and I will personally bring her back to the Ember Pack. Just back off before you two slaughter each other right here."

The immediate threat of violence defused by a slight margin, but the gnawing pain in my chest twisted deeper. My brother had sent him. Kaelen had sent the man who broke me into enemy territory just to drag me back.

"Why does my brother even want me to come back anyway?" I demanded, hating the raw vulnerability leaking into my words. "If he missed me, he would have come to visit."

I knew I was being unfair. I had locked out all visitors for five months. I refused to see Kaelen or Bree because I was terrified they would force me to face the reality of my broken life. Now, that reality was standing in my kitchen, demanding my return.

"He didn't say," Rowan gritted his teeth, his jaw tight. "But I agree with him. You need to come home."

The nerve. The sheer unapologetic nerve.

I lashed out one last desperate time. I needed to hurt him. I needed to inflict a fraction of the agony burning through my veins right now.

"Why do I need to come back?" I snapped, my voice echoing off the walls. "So I can watch you and your girlfriend raise your precious little baby?"

Rowan flinched. A sharp physical reaction, as if I had driven a blade right under his ribs. Satisfaction mixed with bitter bile in my throat.

"Tell my brother I'll come home when I'm good and ready," I hissed, refusing to give him another second of my time. "Now leave me the hell alone."

Without waiting for his reaction, I spun on my heel. I fled back down the hallway, taking the wooden stairs two at a time. My lungs burned. My legs shook so hard I almost tripped on the top step.

I bolted into my bedroom and practically collapsed onto the mattress. I buried my face in the heavy quilt as my heart shattered all over again, the sharp edges slicing open the fragile healing I had achieved over the past one hundred and fifty days.

The raw bleeding pain roared back to life. It felt as though his cruel rejection had happened only yesterday. Five months of hard-fought survival erased in a single agonizing conversation.

I rolled over, staring blankly at the white ceiling. My mind raced, tumbling through a chaotic storm of questions.

Why now? Why did Kaelen suddenly desperately want me back home? My protective brother knew exact what Rowan had done to me. He knew the devastation it caused. If Kaelen was willing to send Rowan into enemy territory to retrieve me, knowing it could spark a war between the packs, there had to be a critically important reason. Something major had shifted.

As much as my soul despised the thought of returning to the house where my life was destroyed, the inescapable truth settled heavy and cold in my gut.

I guess I was finally going home.